Out of Control Teen : What to do When Punishment Doesnt Work

Out of Control Teen : What to do When Punishment Doesnt Work

Just when parents think we have good boundaries, consequences, and routines down for our kids and teens, they throw us another curveball that essentially renders every effort obsolete. When teens act out and are out of control, it can make things even more of a challenge. What previously worked for your teen may not work now at all. Just what is a good consequence for a teenager?

How can you make sure that you can discipline a wildly defiant and rebellious teen?

How do you discipline a teenager who doesn’t care about consequences?

Does your teen ignore the boundaries and consequences you give to him? When children and teens are faced with something that they don’t like, they will often behave in a way that indicates it doesn’t matter to them. If your teen appears to be largely unbothered when he is issued a consequence, or he says, “I don’t care” or “Whatever,” what he is really trying to say is, “Your consequences can’t hurt me.”

This is because consequences and punishments can make teens feel like they are powerless. By making the bold statement that he doesn’t care about the result, your teen is doing what he can to take back his power. The issue with this is that it gives him the sense of power he wants and takes it away from you.

What can you do? One school of thought is to focus less on what it takes to make him care and more on lessons that you want your teen to learn. Consequences aren’t designed to cause teens to apologize. They help your teen alter behavior.

Don’t get drawn into an argument with your teen when he says that he doesn’t care. Instead, tell him that it’s okay if he doesn’t care. He’s still going to be faced with the consequence.

There are a few things that you can try when dealing with an obstinate teen who doesn’t care if he faces the consequences:

  • Make sure that you’re using consequences that will have meaning for him. You don’t always want to cause him discomfort, but you should pick out punishments that will get his attention.
  • Don’t issue consequences while you’re in the midst of an argument. It’s too easy to be too harsh or too lenient when trying to devise punishment plans with emotions running high.
  • Try to skip the speeches. Your teen will likely tune you out if you go heavy on the lectures.
  • Ensure that each consequence is clearly defined. Punishments should be black and white. There should be no room for your teen to interpret the outcomes. It can be beneficial for your teen to understand the punishments ahead of time to know what to expect the next time he acts out.
  • Instead of grounding your teen for an extended period, consider consequences that can end when he accomplishes set tasks. By making the punishments task-oriented instead of time-oriented, you can allow your teen to learn and improve on his behavior.
  • Don’t keep him from going to important events, such as the big game or the prom. Taking away milestone events in your teen’s life will not teach him any lessons. It’ll leave him feeling angry and bitter.

If this approach doesn’t work, what should your next step be? You may get to a point where you feel you’ve tried everything. It may be time to consider an alternative approach that includes a residential treatment center for your teen.

How do you deal with a defiant and disrespectful teenager?

If you’ve tried setting boundaries and establishing consequences, you may feel entirely out of your depths only to see your teen being disobedient and disrespectful. How can you cope with a teen who is willfully defiant and disrespectful?

  • Don’t engage him in an argument, no matter how much he seems to be egging you on.
  • Don’t be insulting or sarcastic when engaging with your teen.
  • Keep your conversations cool, calm, and respectful. Losing your cool will only result in further inflaming the situation
  • If your teen takes a turn for the physically violent, don’t engage at all. Get help from the authorities and take steps to protect yourself and other household members.
  • Seek out therapy for yourself and everyone in the family. Family therapy can help everyone learn better communication skills.

If you’re at the point where you feel that you’re out of options, you should consider a residential treatment center that will give your out-of-control teen a fresh start.

List of consequences for teenagers

When establishing consequences for your teen, you must define them clearly before you need to rely on them. This can put you in a better position to issue the punishment when needed and give your teen less room for interpretation. If you’re at a loss as to what kind of consequences might work for your teen, we’ve got a list of suggestions:

  • Losing his phone for a set period, or during after-school hours.
  • No more tablets, game consoles, or laptops unless specifically used for schoolwork.
  • Being restricted to his bedroom in the evenings and on the weekends when it’s not dinnertime.
  • While it’s not always a good idea to keep your teen from those milestone events, it may be effective to let him know he can only attend a party or other event with friends if he keeps his attitude and behavior in line.
  • If your teen drives, you can restrict his ability to use the car for anything else but going to and from school or work.
  • Assign extra household chores on top of those he is already responsible for.

Making a chart that clearly defines the rules and consequences for your teen can help. Not only does it outline everything clearly for your teen, but it gives him no excuse for breaking the household rules. Keep in mind that it’s perfectly acceptable to adjust the rules and consequences as you and your teen figure out what does and doesn’t work for you.

Just be sure that you communicate well with your teen. In an environment where emotions are already running high, the last thing that you want is for your teen to feel that he is being ambushed by changes he wasn’t expecting or aware of.

If you’re looking for the resources you need to help your out-of-control teen, call HelpYourTeenNow. Our knowledgeable team matches you with the right resources needed to help get your teen and your family as a whole.

Request Free Admissions Information

Step 1 of 3 - Your Contact Info

Written by Natalie

20 Jun, 2022

Recent Posts

A Therapeutic Boarding School Is The Way To Go, Not A Boot Camp

There are many troubled teen programs to consider when parents are looking for help for their struggling son or daughter. Often, the decision for many parents come down between a therapeutic boarding school or a boot camp. So, if you are caught between these choices,...

Suicide in the Media and Tragic Effects on Teenagers

13 Reasons Why In 2017 Netflix aired a TV show called 13 Reasons Why (written as TH1RTEEN R3ASONS WHY), about a 17-year-old girl who recorded a series of tapes in which she explains why she committed suicide. The show focuses on problems typically faced by today’s...

The Pivotal Role Fathers Play in a Teen’s Life

Teens may not want to admit this, Dad, but they need you. Anyone who takes the role of a father – not just a birth father, but also an adoptive father, step-father, or father-figure - plays a pivotal role in a teen’s life. On Father’s Day, this June 16th, let’s take a...

Dance as a Tool to Help Struggling Teens

Sometimes we forget how hard it is to be a young teenager. The push and pull in their world to fit in can be crippling. The sad truth is, suicide is the 3rd leading cause of death of 12-year olds around the world. Think about that for a moment. Just as a child is...

International Day of Families: A Day Just To Focus On Being A Family

The United Nations General Assembly established May 15th as the International Day of Families in 1993. The purpose was to celebrate the role of families in society and develop awareness of issues that affect families all around the world. The UN considers the family...

May is Mental Health Month- Let’s Support Our Struggling Teens

May has been declared Mental Health Month in an effort to increase awareness and promote discussion about mental health issues. There are many kinds of mental illnesses, and millions of people in our country who suffer from mental health, but the one thing that people...

Dear Mothers of Troubled Teens in Therapeutic Boarding Schools

Mother’s Day approaches and your family doesn’t look like the scenes portrayed in Hallmark movies or florist commercials. It’s not the perfect family. Here’s a universal truth: There is no perfect family. The reality is that your teen is in a therapeutic boarding...

The Indirect Benefits Of A Boarding School For Your Troubled Son

When considering sending a struggling teenage son to boarding school for troubled teens, most parents are hoping to address the problems which have troubled their son’s future. While the programs at the boarding school will certainly target the emotional, behavioral,...

You May Also Like…

How to Apologize to Your Teen

How to Apologize to Your Teen

Do you admit it when you’ve made a mistake or lost your temper? Apologizing is not always the easiest thing in the...

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *